Showing posts with label pro se. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pro se. Show all posts

Thursday, July 2, 2009

DO IT YOURSELF DIVORCE PART FOUR: PREPARING A SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT

In the last do it yourself divorce article, I discussed how reaching an agreement is only a step in the process. A parenting plan and marital settlement agreement must be prepared and filed with the Court. This is another area where do it yourself divorce participants can run into trouble. Since most do it yourself divorce participants do not have experience in drafting divorce agreements, its not uncommon to miss important details and end up with an incomplete agreement.

One of the most common omissions is a detailed parenting plan. Many people believe they will simply work matters out as they arise and do not create detailed schedules for timesharing, holidays or vacation time. Do it yourself divorce participants may also forget to discuss extracurricular activities or college expenses. If a dispute arises later, some of these items may be waived because they are not included in a settlement agreement. It is important to take the time to address each and every issue before a problem arises. A divorce attorney or family law mediator may be of assistance in helping a do it yourself divorcing couple identify and reach agreement on all children-related issues.

A do it yourself divorce agreement may also lack time parameters or specifics for the sale or transfer of property. For example, if one person is going to keep a house or other property and needs to refinance to remove the other person’s name, the do it yourself divorce agreement may fail to state when the refinance will take place. Or, if a property is to be sold, the do it yourself divorce agreement may have no language about selecting a realtor, agreeing on a sales price or what to do about repairs and expenses before the home or property is sold.

The above are only a few examples of details that may be overlooked in a do it yourself divorce agreement. It is important to be as specific as possible in order to avoid problems and disputes down the road. Anyone who has specific questions about a do it yourself divorce agreement should consult a divorce attorney.

In the next post, I will discuss the last stage of the divorce process- the final hearing- as well as the matters that come up after a divorce becomes final.

Sunday, June 28, 2009

DO IT YOURSELF DIVORCE PART TWO: GATHERING THE ESSENTIAL FINANCIALS

In the first article about do it yourself divorce, I discussed what to do before getting started. The next step in the do it yourself divorce process is very important in deciding whether this is right for you.

Florida divorce law requires that parties getting divorce file financial affidavits and list all of their assets and liabilities. In order to draft a complete Marital Settlement Agreement, you need to know everything you own and everything you owe. This would include all bank accounts, credit card statements and retirement accounts. It is highly recommended in do it yourself divorce situations that you obtain current statements for each and every account that you and your spouse have, whether the account is in one or both names. In a do it yourself divorce situation, you and your spouse should be on good enough terms that you share this information with one another. All of this information must be listed on a financial affidavit and both parties must sign under oath that they have provided full disclosure to one another of all assets and liabilities and that the information provided is truthful and accurate. You will need this information to decide how you are going to divide your assets and liabilities.

Once you have a Florida financial affidavit and all information about your assets and liabilities, questions may arise. Is an asset or liability marital or nonmarital? How do you split credit card debt? What happens with a retirement account that began before the marriage? What about pensions and profit sharing? A divorce lawyer can advise you about whether an asset or liability is marital or non marital. This is one of the things that should be addressed in your initial divorce consultation. Credit card debt can be a tricky issue if both parties names are on a specific credit card and the debt is to be split. In a do it yourself divorce situation, you need to think about how you are going to divide this debt and how you will protect yourself and your credit if your spouse does not pay his or her share. When it comes to retirement accounts and pensions, you may want to consider hiring a financial professional to perform a valuation of the account, pension or profit sharing. You should also speak with your divorce lawyer about your obligation to divide these assets or your rights to a portion of these assets.

The Florida financial affidavit also requires that both parties list their incomes. What happens if you do not know your monthly income? This is a common question for business owners or those who are paid by commissions. In those situations, it is important to speak with a financial professional, such as an accountant, to get advise regarding how to calculate your monthly income. If you have questions about how much your spouse earns, you should address these questions with a divorce lawyer or an accountant.

These are just a few examples of questions and issues that may arise during the do it yourself divorce process. The financial portion of a divorce may be the most challenging aspect in the do it yourself divorce process. The important thing to keep in mind is that many decisions you make in this part of the process may be binding and non-modifiable so it is crucial that all of your questions are answered before you proceed. If you have questions or concerns about these or other financial aspects of your divorce, speak with your divorce lawyer or accountant before making any decisions about dividing property, assets and liabilities.

Wednesday, June 20, 2007

The Pros and Cons of Pro Se Mediation

Given the high cost of contested divorce litigation and its emotional aftermath, many people are opting for the pro se route. In South Florida, approximately 60% of divorce cases contain at least one unrepresented party. There is a growing market of services available to pro se divorcees, including the, quite sadly unregulated, online services which advertise "Do It Yourself" Divorce and other services for a fee far less than what an attorney would charge. But, as some of my clients have learned by engaging these “services” and receiving less than adequate results, you often get what you pay for.

Pro Se Divorce Mediation has emerged as another popular choice and has become a one stop shopping alternative in the vast array of lawyerless divorce methods. Although many family law mediators are attorneys, they are prohibited from giving legal advice when acting as mediators. However, mediators can prepare the forms which must be filed in conjunction with a divorce, including a marital settlement agreement. Pro se divorce mediation has received some much deserved criticism and some grudging recognition. There is a Florida Bar approved course for mediators to learn the complete process of pro se divorce mediation. But many lawyers continue to believe that pro se mediation is merely an ethics complaint waiting to happen.

Opponents argue that it is impossible to mediate a complete divorce agreement without giving legal advice and that pro se mediation will create an ethical dilemma where a lawyer-mediator is either forced to give legal advice, which violates that Rules For Certified and Court Appointed Mediators or to bite his or her tongue and allow parties to create either an incomplete agreement or one that does not protect the rights of one or both parties, which also violates the Rules.

Proponents, and the pro se public, seem to believe that a cost effective way to divorce is mandated. Many people can't afford to spend thousands of dollars litigating over their property, children or both, and many others do not want to. In many of these instances, the issues are relatively simple, from a legal standpoint. For instance, the parties are both salaried employees, earning similar incomes, and issues such as child support are reduced to a formula that can be calculated. Assets and liabilities are known to both parties and it is just a matter of who gets to keep (and pay for) what.

In cases that are more complicated, where there are more assets to divide, questions involving alimony, pension and social security benefits, valuation issues and/or parties who don't have knowledge of the entire financial picture. These parties are opting for mediation as well and presenting a challenge, if not a dilemma, for a mediator.

It appears that a hybrid solution might be necessary. Mediation can be a useful tool in helping parties resolve certain issues. However, the necessity of obtaining legal advice cannot be ignored either. Some divorcing couples are taking advantage of the limited representation now allowed by the Florida Bar and consulting with lawyers before, after and even during mediation. This allows the parties to negotiate without costly litigation and still receive much needed legal guidance as to their rights and responsibilities.

It is impossible to give an answer as to whether pro se divorce mediation is right or wrong. That depends on the particular case. But it is certain that the public is seeking alternatives to the traditional lawyer driven and costly divorce and that attorneys and mediators are seeking to balance accommodation of the public’s desire with their ethical responsibilities.