It is no secret that divorce filings have decreased in recent months. Many people believe they are in a situation where they "can't afford to divorce". However, two divorce lawyers believe differently.
According to a St. Louis attorney who describes himself as representing men in divorce, the current recession is the ideal time to divorce. If divorce is going to happen, he reasons, its far better to divorce at a time when assets and income are at their lowest.
A Tampa based divorce attorney who represents women agrees, but for different reasons.
The recession can be used to his client's advantage as well, especially in what were two income families. If a woman has been laid off from her job, it stands to reason that she will have a need for increased child support and alimony.
Its hard to say whether many people agree with the reasoning of either lawyer. One thing is clear: divorce rates in south florida have declined. In Miami-Dade County, divorces dropped from 3,239 for the first three months of 2008 to 3,196 during the same period in 2009. In Broward, the number dropped from 2,148 for the first quarter of 2008 to 1,543 for the same period in 2009.
No one can say which gender will fare better by divorcing in a recession. But the one encouraging thing I see, as a collaborative attorney and a mediator, is that many couples are not buying into this "seize the opportunity to divorce now and pay less to your spouse" mentality. They seem to recognize that their spouse may not go quietly with less money and will probably launch a counter attack, i.e. a highly contested divorce. A highly contested divorce = lots of money spent in lawyer fees. Forget dividing what is left of the 401k- it will be liquidated and divided between your two attorneys.
If this happens, the economic gain advertised by these lawyers, i.e., less assets to give to your spouse, less alimony/child support, etc., will be offset by the high cost of contested divorce litigation. As the saying goes, only the lawyers will win. It appears that many recognize this, preferring to wait to divide their union in less economically distressed times and, perhaps ironically, have decided that, at least for the present, that they are in this together.
Divorce and family mediation blog. Information about divorce, child custody, child support and mediation. Lori Barkus P.A.*www.barkuslaw.com
Showing posts with label divorce and women. Show all posts
Showing posts with label divorce and women. Show all posts
Sunday, July 19, 2009
Wednesday, March 11, 2009
Yours, Mine and Ours
One of the most popular misconceptions I hear is about separate accounts. Many people seem to believe that by simply placing an account in their own name, it is non-marital property. I also hear the same rationale for debts, especially credit card debts. Many people seem to believe that, if a credit card is in the name of one spouse only, that debt belongs to that spouse. This is not always the case.
Under Florida law, a marital asset is anything acquired or enhanced during the marriage regardless of how it is titled. Basically, every dollar earned during a marriage belongs equally to both parties. If one spouse has a separate account and deposits his/her paycheck that was earned while the parties are married into that account, the account now has marital funds. Even if the account was opened prior to the marriage and was, at one time, a non marital asset, there is now an issue with commingling of the funds in that account. The same may be true for retirement accounts.
When it comes to credit card debt, just as money earned during the marriage belongs to both parties equally, debts that were acquired during the marriage are the equal burden of the parties. At least, this is the starting presumption. There are several factors that can affect whether the debt is marital and how it should be divided, and paid for, especially when it is in the name of one party and not both. And it is also important to keep in mind that, even if a Court Order or settlement agreement states that a party is responsible for a debt, this will not stop a creditor or collection agency from collecting from the party whose name is attached to the debt. If the debt cannot be transferred to the party who will be responsible for it, there must be some safeguard in place to protect the party holding the debt in case the other party does not pay.
The above is intended for general information purposes only and should not be considered legal advice. It is highly recommended to consult with an attorney before making any decisions or signing any settlement regarding the division of assets or liabilities.
Under Florida law, a marital asset is anything acquired or enhanced during the marriage regardless of how it is titled. Basically, every dollar earned during a marriage belongs equally to both parties. If one spouse has a separate account and deposits his/her paycheck that was earned while the parties are married into that account, the account now has marital funds. Even if the account was opened prior to the marriage and was, at one time, a non marital asset, there is now an issue with commingling of the funds in that account. The same may be true for retirement accounts.
When it comes to credit card debt, just as money earned during the marriage belongs to both parties equally, debts that were acquired during the marriage are the equal burden of the parties. At least, this is the starting presumption. There are several factors that can affect whether the debt is marital and how it should be divided, and paid for, especially when it is in the name of one party and not both. And it is also important to keep in mind that, even if a Court Order or settlement agreement states that a party is responsible for a debt, this will not stop a creditor or collection agency from collecting from the party whose name is attached to the debt. If the debt cannot be transferred to the party who will be responsible for it, there must be some safeguard in place to protect the party holding the debt in case the other party does not pay.
The above is intended for general information purposes only and should not be considered legal advice. It is highly recommended to consult with an attorney before making any decisions or signing any settlement regarding the division of assets or liabilities.
Sunday, January 18, 2009
Divorcing when times are tough
Its no secret that money is one of the biggest stressors and topic of frequent arguments. In the present economy, most people are concerned about, if not completely frightened over, their financial situation. Concern leads to fighting and, in unions which were already rocky, the present economic woes are enough to bring things to an end. But, with layoffs happening or looming, houses not selling and their values decreasing more and more each month, many people are becoming stuck between wanting to end their marriages and not being financially able to do so. More and more couples find themselves in this situation. And the frequently asked question is: what do you do when you can't afford to divorce?
The first step is to figure out where you are financially. I advise clients to write out their monthly financial expenses and figure out their present monthly need. Once you have that information, you are in a much better place to make decisions. The next step is to separate the fixed expenses such as monthly mortgage and taxes from the discretionary ones such as cable and cleaning service and figure out which can be reduced and which can be eliminated altogether. This gets you to the actual bottom line amount needed on a monthly basis.
For many people these days, it would be difficult or impossible to pay the monthly household expenses on one income, even with reducing or eliminating those expenses. If one person moves out, he or she now has to pay rent and utilities elsewhere, meaning that there is not enough money to go around. If this is the case, then asking or forcing your spouse to move out of the house immediately simply will not work.
In a previous post, I offered some suggestions for those who need to continue living together during and after divorce. In this post, I'll address more of the practicalities such as bill paying and separating finances. While it is easier to maintain a joint account, deposit all funds into that account and pay bills jointly, this situation may not work for some. It leads to disagreements about the discretionary spending of each party. Once a couple has separated, neither party wants their earnings to pay for the other parties meals out, shopping or other forms of entertainment. If a couple is going to be living together for an indefinite period of time, such as, until the house sells, a preferred course of action may be to split accounts rather than maintain completely joint funds. Both parties can pay the joint living expenses such as the mortgage and utilities and agreed upon children's expenses and can do so from a joint account. But personal charges and spending should be kept separate and paid from separate funds.
Another suggested course of action is to separate credit cards. Hopefully, each party has at least one credit card in their own name or enough credit history to open one. Removing each other as a signer from the credit cards in the name of the other may also be recommended. A joint credit card can be used to pay agreed joint expenses and separate cards can be used for each party's personal expenses.
Equity lines, if you still have one these days, should only be used by agreement and for joint expenses. Keep in mind that, if you file for divorce later on, or have already filed, you will have to account to your spouse, and vice versa, for any funds removed from an equity line. Withdrawing funds from an equity line without telling your spouse and/or using them to pay your separate debt and expenses will cost both of you in the long run. This will only create confusion, anger and more attorneys fees spent in determining how the funds were spent.
If you have a car with a high monthly payment, look into selling or trading it in, if possible. This may not be an option if you owe more than your car is worth. But if there is some equity, even a minimal amount, you may be able to lower this payment and reduce your monthly expenses.
If you own a house that neither of you can or want to maintain, consider your options carefully. Find out the present value of your home and the likelihood of it being sold. Ask a realtor for a list of recent sales of comparable homes and the selling prices. If you owe more than your home is worth, talk to a bank representative or other professional about your options.
Keep in mind that the above are only suggestions and not legal advice. Every situation is different and what works for one couple may not work for another. Before taking any steps to separate finances or reach an agreement with your spouse about how to pay bills and how much should be paid by either party, it is extremely important to seek the advice of a financial or legal professional.
The first step is to figure out where you are financially. I advise clients to write out their monthly financial expenses and figure out their present monthly need. Once you have that information, you are in a much better place to make decisions. The next step is to separate the fixed expenses such as monthly mortgage and taxes from the discretionary ones such as cable and cleaning service and figure out which can be reduced and which can be eliminated altogether. This gets you to the actual bottom line amount needed on a monthly basis.
For many people these days, it would be difficult or impossible to pay the monthly household expenses on one income, even with reducing or eliminating those expenses. If one person moves out, he or she now has to pay rent and utilities elsewhere, meaning that there is not enough money to go around. If this is the case, then asking or forcing your spouse to move out of the house immediately simply will not work.
In a previous post, I offered some suggestions for those who need to continue living together during and after divorce. In this post, I'll address more of the practicalities such as bill paying and separating finances. While it is easier to maintain a joint account, deposit all funds into that account and pay bills jointly, this situation may not work for some. It leads to disagreements about the discretionary spending of each party. Once a couple has separated, neither party wants their earnings to pay for the other parties meals out, shopping or other forms of entertainment. If a couple is going to be living together for an indefinite period of time, such as, until the house sells, a preferred course of action may be to split accounts rather than maintain completely joint funds. Both parties can pay the joint living expenses such as the mortgage and utilities and agreed upon children's expenses and can do so from a joint account. But personal charges and spending should be kept separate and paid from separate funds.
Another suggested course of action is to separate credit cards. Hopefully, each party has at least one credit card in their own name or enough credit history to open one. Removing each other as a signer from the credit cards in the name of the other may also be recommended. A joint credit card can be used to pay agreed joint expenses and separate cards can be used for each party's personal expenses.
Equity lines, if you still have one these days, should only be used by agreement and for joint expenses. Keep in mind that, if you file for divorce later on, or have already filed, you will have to account to your spouse, and vice versa, for any funds removed from an equity line. Withdrawing funds from an equity line without telling your spouse and/or using them to pay your separate debt and expenses will cost both of you in the long run. This will only create confusion, anger and more attorneys fees spent in determining how the funds were spent.
If you have a car with a high monthly payment, look into selling or trading it in, if possible. This may not be an option if you owe more than your car is worth. But if there is some equity, even a minimal amount, you may be able to lower this payment and reduce your monthly expenses.
If you own a house that neither of you can or want to maintain, consider your options carefully. Find out the present value of your home and the likelihood of it being sold. Ask a realtor for a list of recent sales of comparable homes and the selling prices. If you owe more than your home is worth, talk to a bank representative or other professional about your options.
Keep in mind that the above are only suggestions and not legal advice. Every situation is different and what works for one couple may not work for another. Before taking any steps to separate finances or reach an agreement with your spouse about how to pay bills and how much should be paid by either party, it is extremely important to seek the advice of a financial or legal professional.
Tuesday, February 5, 2008
The Seven Deadly Sins of Divorcing Women
The Seven Deadly Sins of Divorcing Women
We have all heard of the seven deadly sins, and most of us can name at least a few. When it comes to women and divorce, the transgressions are not gluttony, envy or pride, but they can be quite damaging. Below is a list of what I call the seven deadly sins, or biggest mistakes commonly committed by divorcing women.
1. Asking for too little: Women often feel guilty about divorce and responsible for their spouse. As a result, women often shortchange themselves in divorce settlements, accepting less than they deserve or, in some cases, less than what they need to live. I strongly encourage my clients to work towards settlement, but also stress that settlement must be fair. Under Florida law, both parties are equal partners to a marriage and there is no fault in ending it. The main goal of settlement is not just to close the marriage chapter but to make sure both parties have enough resources to go forward. Settling for less than an equal share and not enough for the wife and children to live on is simply not fair.
2. Asking too much: On the opposite side of the spectrum, some women have unrealistic expectations about what to expect from a divorce settlement. Rather than listening to their lawyers, many seek the advice of friends, relatives and others who divulge the details of their divorce settlements as though they are the norm, rather than the outcome of their specific set of circumstances. Many couples spend tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars litigating their divorce because one party believes they are entitled to more than the law will allow. Much like the deadly sin of greed, unrealistic expectations can be emotionally and financially costly.
3. Avoiding confrontation: By nature and nurture, women are taught to be non-confrontational while men are taught to be assertive. Men tend to have less trouble taking a strong stand while negotiating or litigating. Many women tend to want to keep the peace and, even in the midst of a divorce, will back off from asserting a reasonable position or pursuing something to which they are entitled. While most divorces can, and should, be settled, there are instances where it is necessary to go forward. In a highly emotional state, it is difficult, if not impossible to know the difference. But not taking a stand can be as costly an error as taking an unreasonable one.
4. Sweating the small stuff: Divorce is emotional for both parties, but men and women handle it differently. Men tend to hide their emotions by fighting or withdrawing while women allow their feelings greater reign. While this is an important part of the healing process, it leads many women to focus on details which, while important, are not legally relevant. This, in turn, leads to a lack of focus on the important aspects and increased costs as a result of fighting over things that are not worth the money spent to litigate them.
5. Paying too high a price: One of the first questions my female clients ask is whether they can keep the home. One of the first questions I ask them is whether they should. Many women will sacrifice everything to remain in the marital home. While it is the right decision if financial circumstances allow for it, maintaining a large mortgage and household expenses can leave a woman with an overwhelming financial burden. Deciding to stay in the home, either by buying out your spouse or taking the home in place of alimony, is not a decision that should be made for emotional reasons, but for sound financial ones.
6. Forgetting that knowledge is power: More and more women are wage earners, but a significant percentage still have no knowledge of joint assets and finances. One party, in many cases, the husband, makes all financial decisions. At the outset of divorce, women in this situation spend considerable time and money investigating the financial picture and, in worst case situations, trying to locate hidden assets. Those who are equal partners in financial decisions or, at least, have knowledge of money expenses, accounts and assets, are in a far better bargaining postion.
7. Waiting too long: Many people, men and women alike, take a long time to reach the difficult decision to end a marriage. Trying everything to make it work, a step I highly support, is one thing; but there are those who, when faced with the knowledge that their partner is depleting assets or even planning for divorce, take the hiding-their-head-in-the-sand approach and do nothing for a period of time. It is understandable that it takes a great deal of strength to reach the decision to divorce, but, in these circumstances, waiting too long can prove disastrous. By the time these women file for divorce, debts may have become too large to handle without liquidating assets and money may have disappeared without a trace.
Finding the right lawyer at the right time can help avoid these costly mistakes. A knowledgeable and neutral advocate can provide much needed advice at this difficult time. Even if the woman has engaged in any of this costly behavior, a divorce attorney can help reverse the damage before an agreement is reached and the case is closed, preventing a costly mistake from having a permanent outcome.
We have all heard of the seven deadly sins, and most of us can name at least a few. When it comes to women and divorce, the transgressions are not gluttony, envy or pride, but they can be quite damaging. Below is a list of what I call the seven deadly sins, or biggest mistakes commonly committed by divorcing women.
1. Asking for too little: Women often feel guilty about divorce and responsible for their spouse. As a result, women often shortchange themselves in divorce settlements, accepting less than they deserve or, in some cases, less than what they need to live. I strongly encourage my clients to work towards settlement, but also stress that settlement must be fair. Under Florida law, both parties are equal partners to a marriage and there is no fault in ending it. The main goal of settlement is not just to close the marriage chapter but to make sure both parties have enough resources to go forward. Settling for less than an equal share and not enough for the wife and children to live on is simply not fair.
2. Asking too much: On the opposite side of the spectrum, some women have unrealistic expectations about what to expect from a divorce settlement. Rather than listening to their lawyers, many seek the advice of friends, relatives and others who divulge the details of their divorce settlements as though they are the norm, rather than the outcome of their specific set of circumstances. Many couples spend tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars litigating their divorce because one party believes they are entitled to more than the law will allow. Much like the deadly sin of greed, unrealistic expectations can be emotionally and financially costly.
3. Avoiding confrontation: By nature and nurture, women are taught to be non-confrontational while men are taught to be assertive. Men tend to have less trouble taking a strong stand while negotiating or litigating. Many women tend to want to keep the peace and, even in the midst of a divorce, will back off from asserting a reasonable position or pursuing something to which they are entitled. While most divorces can, and should, be settled, there are instances where it is necessary to go forward. In a highly emotional state, it is difficult, if not impossible to know the difference. But not taking a stand can be as costly an error as taking an unreasonable one.
4. Sweating the small stuff: Divorce is emotional for both parties, but men and women handle it differently. Men tend to hide their emotions by fighting or withdrawing while women allow their feelings greater reign. While this is an important part of the healing process, it leads many women to focus on details which, while important, are not legally relevant. This, in turn, leads to a lack of focus on the important aspects and increased costs as a result of fighting over things that are not worth the money spent to litigate them.
5. Paying too high a price: One of the first questions my female clients ask is whether they can keep the home. One of the first questions I ask them is whether they should. Many women will sacrifice everything to remain in the marital home. While it is the right decision if financial circumstances allow for it, maintaining a large mortgage and household expenses can leave a woman with an overwhelming financial burden. Deciding to stay in the home, either by buying out your spouse or taking the home in place of alimony, is not a decision that should be made for emotional reasons, but for sound financial ones.
6. Forgetting that knowledge is power: More and more women are wage earners, but a significant percentage still have no knowledge of joint assets and finances. One party, in many cases, the husband, makes all financial decisions. At the outset of divorce, women in this situation spend considerable time and money investigating the financial picture and, in worst case situations, trying to locate hidden assets. Those who are equal partners in financial decisions or, at least, have knowledge of money expenses, accounts and assets, are in a far better bargaining postion.
7. Waiting too long: Many people, men and women alike, take a long time to reach the difficult decision to end a marriage. Trying everything to make it work, a step I highly support, is one thing; but there are those who, when faced with the knowledge that their partner is depleting assets or even planning for divorce, take the hiding-their-head-in-the-sand approach and do nothing for a period of time. It is understandable that it takes a great deal of strength to reach the decision to divorce, but, in these circumstances, waiting too long can prove disastrous. By the time these women file for divorce, debts may have become too large to handle without liquidating assets and money may have disappeared without a trace.
Finding the right lawyer at the right time can help avoid these costly mistakes. A knowledgeable and neutral advocate can provide much needed advice at this difficult time. Even if the woman has engaged in any of this costly behavior, a divorce attorney can help reverse the damage before an agreement is reached and the case is closed, preventing a costly mistake from having a permanent outcome.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)